- The Page Sage
- Posts
- Synthetic Stories, Human Consequences
Synthetic Stories, Human Consequences
When the voice disappears, what remains? A reflective look at AI authorship, creativity, and the future of fiction.
Volume II: The Rise of the Machines
AI Authors and the Ethics of the Page
Something subtle is shifting on the digital shelf.
Books still look like books. Covers. Titles. Author names — some familiar, some not.
But increasingly, those names are placeholders.
And the stories? Constructed by machines.
There’s no announcement. No disclaimer.
Just another novel, another new release, quietly added to the flood.
The Landscape of Automation
Since 2023, thousands of books have been published by authors who may not exist.
What began as a quiet experiment in AI-assisted writing has grown into a silent industry — one that now produces entire catalogues without a human voice behind them.
In 2025, these titles appear daily — nestled into bestseller lists, recommendation feeds, and self-publishing dashboards.
They blend in just well enough:
A shadowy biography, if any
A plausible, if indistinct, blurb
A title shaped by algorithmic convention
A price low enough to tempt, but not to alarm
And it works. Because the platforms aren’t designed to question authorship.
They’re designed to distribute at scale.
And in a system built for volume, speed prevails.
When Voice Becomes Invisible
One of the quiet assumptions driving this shift is simple — and cynical:
People don’t care who wrote it.
They just want content. Fast, familiar, consumable.
That belief is what makes AI authorship so attractive to opportunists. If no one’s really paying attention, why not generate ten thrillers instead of one? Why not optimise for volume, visibility, and keywords — and let the machine handle the rest?
But there’s more than indifference at play here — there’s intent.
These books aren’t just experiments in automation. They’re attempts at monetisation.
At taking up space on the digital shelf. At capturing clicks, purchases, royalties — without a real writer in sight.
Some authors now publish across genres with remarkable speed — dozens of books in a few months, spanning everything from thrillers to philosophy. The names are unfamiliar. The blurbs are vague. And the voices, often, feel absent.
And every one of those titles competes for visibility — often at the expense of authors who are still doing the work.
Writers like John Scalzi or Annalee Newitz, who build entire futures.
Like Stacy Nathaniel Jackson, whose characters feel lived-in from the start.
Or Mira Grant, who blends science and story with care.
These are books made with time, perspective, revision — not just keywords.
In a forest of pages, how do you tell those written by hand — from those that never touched one?
There’s no single rule, but for many, the use of AI in fiction — especially when unacknowledged — feels uncomfortable.
And not without reason.
Writing isn’t just about getting the words down.
It’s about voice.
Perspective.
Presence.
That presence is what gives a book its meaning — it’s not manufactured.
It’s one thing to use a tool to shape a sentence or untangle a structure.
It’s another to hand over the entire process and present the result as human.
To release a machine-written novel under a name — not as an experiment, but as a product.
That’s not collaboration.
It’s impersonation.
And when it’s done quietly, at scale, and with profit as the goal — it doesn’t just blur the line.
It erases it.
Readers aren’t just buying a story.
They’re stepping into a world — and trusting that someone built it.
Perhaps what matters most isn't how fast a book is written, but who's waiting on the other side of the page.
Until next time,
— The Page Sage
The Page Sage is reader-supported. When you discover a book you love through one of our lists, using the links provided helps keep the curation flowing — at no extra cost to you.